Chapter by Arianna Falbo, David Thorstad, and Dennis Whitcomb: “Take a moment to consider how different your life would be, if you did not have the ability to inquire. (Notice that in order to do this, you will need to engage in a bit of inquiry.) Without the ability to inquire, you surely would know much less about the world. Your life would be boring and uninteresting, at best.
We don’t live passive intellectual lives. We don’t relate to our evidence in the same way that pet goldfish relate to their food. We don’t float through life, absorbing the bits of evidence that happen to pass us by. We’re not “information filter-feeders” (J. Friedman forthcoming). We are more like sharks: we take action. If you need to know whether your neighbor is home or how to get to the airport, you inquire: you knock on doors and send text messages, or you ask your GPS system to show you the way. Inquiry is an indispensable part of daily life, and our lives would be drastically different—for the worse—without it.
Inquiry is a central topic across many philosophical traditions, though surprisingly it received only minimal attention in late twentieth century epistemology. This literature primarily analyzed epistemic states like justified belief or knowledge. Recently, however, scholarship in epistemology has undergone a “zetetic turn”, with many epistemologists now focusing on processes of inquiry that generate states like justified belief and knowledge. (The word “zetetic” comes from the Greek word “ζητητικός” (zētētikós) which means “proceeding by inquiry or investigation.”) Against the background of recent work in epistemology, the zetetic turn may seem like a historical outlier. However, questions about inquiry have been central throughout the history of philosophy. In this sense, it may be more accurate to describe the zetetic turn as a zetetic return towards questions that have continually animated philosophical theorizing.
Inquiry-focused epistemology, or “zetetic epistemology”, poses at least two types of questions about inquiry. First, there are questions about the nature of inquiry. For example, some have proposed that inquiry is a question-directed activity with a defining goal or constitutive aim, and that inquiry is intimately connected to a class of attitudes, like wonder or curiosity, which are directed towards questions. Second, and relatedly, there are questions about the norms of inquiry. For example, theorists have developed accounts of the proper conduct of inquiry. They have also discussed the relationship between norms of inquiry (or zetetic norms) and more traditional epistemic norms governing states like belief or knowledge…(More)”.