Article by Andrew Whelan: “Etymologically, “bureaucracy” is a joke, and like many good jokes, it expresses a critical truth in a comic register. Bureaucratie — “government by desks” — is attributed to the French economist and administrator Jacques Claude Marie Vincent de Gournay, who became the country’s Administrator of Commerce in 1751. The term was originally coined to ridicule the machine-like agents of a protectionist state.
Several foundational liberal objections to bureaucracy have long appeared in the literature.
First, bureaucratic systems can separate organizations from the values and purposes they were created to serve. In other words, it becomes possible for institutions — and for entire societies — to follow the “correct” courses of action in terms of the internal structures of rule-bound activity, while losing sight of their original and proper “ends.” Bureaucracies are internally coherent and “rational” yet produce disastrous social outcomes, such as ecological collapse or militarized interstate competition.
Secondly, bureaucracies cultivate and reward functionaries who suppress their own ethics to perform their duties effectively and objectively. The moral character of the administrator thus comes under scrutiny. As the German sociologist Max Weber argued, bureaucracy emphasizes calculability and dispassion. Action should demonstrably follow rules, outcomes can and should be measured, and procedures can and should be improved through the evidence base they produce. The technical precision of bureaucracy requires neutral and replaceable administrators. As a result, a well-developed bureaucracy is, in Weber’s term, “dehumanized”: it conducts work without influence from personal interests or emotions.
At the same time, however, the bureau’s emphasis on detached calculation can weaken the moral judgment of the people who operate it. Weber thus described how a judge, functioning
in the bureaucratic state with its rational laws, is more or less an automaton of paragraphs: the legal documents, together with the costs and fees, are dropped in at the top with the expectation that the judgment will emerge at the bottom together with more or less sound arguments.
An uncanny transformation takes place. Living people become the puppets of textual and documental procedures. The moral ends and values of individuals and collectives are deferred, collapsed into depersonalized task segmentation, process efficiency, an ever more refined division of labor, and the documentation practices required to make it all work. Social reality and morality become “structured, but meaningless.” The person is weakened as the administrative apparatus is awfully enlivened…(More)”