Stefaan Verhulst
Chapter by Arianna Falbo, David Thorstad, and Dennis Whitcomb: “Take a moment to consider how different your life would be, if you did not have the ability to inquire. (Notice that in order to do this, you will need to engage in a bit of inquiry.) Without the ability to inquire, you surely would know much less about the world. Your life would be boring and uninteresting, at best.
We don’t live passive intellectual lives. We don’t relate to our evidence in the same way that pet goldfish relate to their food. We don’t float through life, absorbing the bits of evidence that happen to pass us by. We’re not “information filter-feeders” (J. Friedman forthcoming). We are more like sharks: we take action. If you need to know whether your neighbor is home or how to get to the airport, you inquire: you knock on doors and send text messages, or you ask your GPS system to show you the way. Inquiry is an indispensable part of daily life, and our lives would be drastically different—for the worse—without it.
Inquiry is a central topic across many philosophical traditions, though surprisingly it received only minimal attention in late twentieth century epistemology. This literature primarily analyzed epistemic states like justified belief or knowledge. Recently, however, scholarship in epistemology has undergone a “zetetic turn”, with many epistemologists now focusing on processes of inquiry that generate states like justified belief and knowledge. (The word “zetetic” comes from the Greek word “ζητητικός” (zētētikós) which means “proceeding by inquiry or investigation.”) Against the background of recent work in epistemology, the zetetic turn may seem like a historical outlier. However, questions about inquiry have been central throughout the history of philosophy. In this sense, it may be more accurate to describe the zetetic turn as a zetetic return towards questions that have continually animated philosophical theorizing.
Inquiry-focused epistemology, or “zetetic epistemology”, poses at least two types of questions about inquiry. First, there are questions about the nature of inquiry. For example, some have proposed that inquiry is a question-directed activity with a defining goal or constitutive aim, and that inquiry is intimately connected to a class of attitudes, like wonder or curiosity, which are directed towards questions. Second, and relatedly, there are questions about the norms of inquiry. For example, theorists have developed accounts of the proper conduct of inquiry. They have also discussed the relationship between norms of inquiry (or zetetic norms) and more traditional epistemic norms governing states like belief or knowledge…(More)”.
Article by Stefaan Verhulst: “…AI is moving from ingesting and producing words and pictures to acting on objects, spaces and bodies.
As with earlier waves of technical innovation, including our current AI moment, data will be at the center of this shift—and, once again, we are at risk of repeating the same data mistakes. As I have written elsewhere, the era of big data and AI has been marked by three asymmetries. First, there has been a data asymmetry, largely because actors working in the public interest could not reach the data that private companies held. There has also been an information asymmetry, because people did not know what was being collected about them or what it was being used for. And finally, there has been an agency asymmetry, because even when people did know their data was being used, they had limited influence over its reuse.
Physical AI is on course to reproduce all three asymmetries and in ways that may be even more problematic for our access and agency. Physical AI’s raw material is not what we post but what we think, how we move, what we touch, and who happens to be in the room.
The good news is that the field is still emerging—there may be time for us to choose a different path…(More)”.
Article and report by Eurocities: “Research partnerships are increasingly helping European cities test new ideas. However, the harder task is making scientific knowledge part of everyday urban decisions.
As city governments confront housing shortages, climate change and growing inequalities, they face increasing pressure to find effective solutions with limited resources.
The stakes extend beyond better public services. Misinformation, pressure on public trust and the rapid development of artificial intelligence are increasing the need for reliable evidence that residents and policymakers can understand and scrutinise.
Stronger cooperation with universities and research institutions can help cities respond to these pressures, improve policymaking and make better-informed decisions.
A new report, City-science collaboration in European cities, published by Eurocities and CRAFT (DAStU, Politecnico di Milano), examines how cities are building these partnerships and what is needed to make them more effective. The publication starts with the experience of municipal administrations, focusing on the questions they need answered, the partnerships they build and the obstacles that prevent research from informing action.
Drawing on contributions from 31 cities across Europe, the report shows that access to research alone is not enough. Lasting partnerships, dedicated staff and political backing are needed to turn scientific knowledge into better decisions.

Cities are embracing science, but challenges remain
The gap revealed by the report is striking. 70% of the cities surveyed collaborate with researchers on pilot projects, but only 30% use scientific partnerships to evaluate policies and learn from the results.
“The important question is not only whether cities collaborate with researchers, but how that collaboration changes the way they understand problems and develop responses,” says Alice Ranzini, Research Fellow, DAStU, Politecnico di Milano, one of the report’s editors. “Knowledge becomes useful through relationships, shared questions and the ability to learn together.”…(More)”.
Article by Samuel Greengard: “When business leaders, government officials, and others seek predictability in a highly unpredictable world, they turn to forecasts. Historically, the most accurate prognostications have come from a group of humans called superforecasters, who weigh probabilities and analyze questions before reaching conclusions.
These individuals—the top 2% of forecasters—perform about 30% better than professional intelligence analysts with access to classified information, according to research conducted by Barbara Mellers and Philip Tetlock. But now things are getting more complicated as AI forecasting enters the picture.
“AI has transformed trading in prediction markets and in financial markets more generally,” said Rajiv Sethi, a professor of economics at Barnard College, Columbia University, and an external professor at the Santa Fe Institute. “Now there’s a question of whether superforecasters will become obsolete due to the AI revolution.”
According to ForecastBench, a benchmarking tool that scores AI models against human forecasters, model accuracy has climbed steadily over the past two years, reaching near parity with superforecasters. Yet parity isn’t judgment, and a growing number of observers are concerned that profit incentives and a lack of visibility into how prediction systems function could invite trouble.
A growing question is whether it’s acceptable to trade explanation for accuracy. “We’re not yet at a point where anyone is willing to take the best forecasting models and rely on them for high-stakes decisions,” said Ezra Karger, a senior economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago who leads the team that built ForecastBench…(More)”.
Article by Vijayendra Rao: “In 1992, India amended its constitution to create some 250,000 elected village governments covering roughly 800 million people — the largest exercise in democratic decentralization in human history. The effects of this 73rd Amendment have varied enormously across states. In Kerala, an extraordinary People’s Campaign in 1996 created a system of nested participatory planning. Street-level groups deliberate on their needs, which are passed on to a ward-level assembly, then percolate upward to a village assembly where all expressed needs are prioritized and matched with budgets.
Over the course of the year, the agreed-upon projects are implemented and monitored in active collaboration with citizens.In other states, the same assemblies, created by the same amendment, are ceremonial rooms where nothing important is decided. In the 300 village-meeting transcripts that Paromita Sanyal and I analyzed for “Oral Democracy,” we found that differences in literacy, caste or wealth inequality did not explain how well these village assemblies worked. They were driven by whether the state government actually wanted decentralization to work – whether it devolved real money and real authority to the assemblies. The same constitutional amendment produced very divergent realities..(More)”.
Book edited by Marc Rotenberg and April Yoder: “…brings together the principal international agreements, national laws, policy frameworks, and governance instruments shaping the future of artificial intelligence.
Building on the widely used 2025 edition, the new Sourcebook documents a remarkable period in the development of AI governance. What began with ethical principles and voluntary guidelines has evolved into national legislation, international treaties, regulatory institutions, and increasingly concrete obligations.
The new edition highlights the growing international convergence around transparency, accountability, public safety, human rights, democratic governance, and meaningful human control over AI systems…(More)”.
Article by Brett Goldstein: “On Oct. 29, hackers that FBI analysts link to North Korea stole nearly $6.4 billion from Binance, the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchange — roughly four times the previous record for a crypto theft.
About a week earlier, the National Security Agency told anyone running a website on PHP, the programming language behind roughly 7 in 10 websites, to install an emergency fix or take the site offline after vulnerabilities were discovered. In Japan, more than 20 major companies recently suffered cyberattacks, and a ruling-party official called it “a state of emergency in cyberspace.” My friends who run banks and keep the lights on in critical infrastructure are using the word “panic.” My friends at the artificial intelligence frontier labs are more blunt: The next couple of years are going to be brutal.
The rumblings shaking the internet are only the beginning. The systems we run our daily lives on are far more fragile than people realize, and the sins of our cyber past are coming due.
It’s uncertain whether AI was used in these attacks, but cyberattacks have multiplied and gotten better. Finding a serious software flaw used to be a needle-in-a-haystack hunt for a skilled hacker. Modern AI hands the haystack to a fast, easy-to-use machine and then hands the machine to both elite and amateur hackers.
Unfortunately, the haystack is enormous, because engineers and system architects constructed it that way. For decades, developers built software quickly and badly because the cost of getting it wrong was never high. I know; I was part of it. I was an early employee at OpenTable, a digital restaurant reservation system, and we asked whether our code worked, not whether it was safe. Speed was our sin. Later, as chief information officer for the city of Chicago, I saw a different sin: scarcity. With the budget stretched to breaking, an old system that still worked stayed up because we didn’t have the money to replace it.
For most of those years, few understood cybersecurity well enough to know what we were skipping. Those sins — speed, scarcity and ignorance — created a thousand shortcuts in a million systems. Every one of them is still out there, waiting to be found.
Look at the PHP flaws. Security researchers used AI to find them, in code written in 2012. Within 45 minutes of their official disclosure, the internet security company Cloudflare was seeing tens of thousands of break-in attempts. Within two hours, hundreds of thousands. Within 24 hours, millions. Then the security firm Bitsight found that nearly 60 percent of exposed PHP servers run versions so old that no official fix exists for them; a week after the fix came out, only about a third of the servers it tracked had installed the patch. Bad software is like asbestos. Asbestos was cheap and no one understood the health consequences, so it went everywhere. Bad software is now everywhere too, and we are starting to see how toxic it can be.
Now consider that two systems help hold up the internet: Border Gateway Protocol, which directs traffic across the internet, and Domain Name System, the internet’s phone book, which turns “washingtonpost.com” into the string of numbers machines actually use. Both date to the 1980s, and neither was built for the scrutiny they are about to face…(More)”.
Special Issue of Vital City: “In our lifetimes, it’s hard to think of a topic that has been on as many people’s minds as artificial intelligence these last few years.
Since ChatGPT began dazzling users with the seeming authority and ersatz humanity of its responses back in late 2022 — and with every new model released by OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and their competitors capable of deeper, faster thinking and agentic action — everyone’s been trying to make sense of what our new robot helpers (or overlords) mean for our economy, culture and democracy. You hear it at kitchen tables and in classrooms, at dive bars and at fancy parties. This is the rare case where the general public may be out in front of elite actors in politics and universities.
The doomer version of the questions swirling around go like this: Will AI replace workers en masse in a range of industries? Devastate human relationships already scrambled by the ubiquity of social media? Hollow out the creative process? Make it utterly impossible to tell disinformation from fact, and supercharge fraudsters? Lead to widespread cognitive offloading or downright cheating in our schools, emptying education of its point? (Oh, and will the advent of superintelligence end civilization as we know it?)
The techno-optimist version sounds different: Will AI take over the drudgery that eats up so much of our days? Give people living in isolation a source of intelligent help at any hour? Put new creative tools in the hands of those who never had the means to make films, music or software? Help journalists and citizens check claims faster than liars can spread them? Give every student, no matter family income, a tutor that adjusts to how they learn? (And oh, will AI soon cure cancer?)
We are as interested in all this as the next Homo sapiens, although, perhaps inevitably, our answers tend to come out in the unsatisfying middle. Instead of wrestling with either the dark portents of a Skynet future or the utopian hype of tech hucksters, as an urban policy journal, we want to ask a basic set of questions: What can these new technologies do for cities? What capabilities will they unlock? And, just as important, what risks will they pose?
Cities in general and New York City in particular differ from suburbs and rural areas in important ways. They are densely packed centers of economic activity, with more than their share of knowledge workers on the one hand and people in poverty on the other. They have high tax bills with expansive (if hole-riddled) safety nets, large police forces and elaborate transit networks.
All this is fertile ground for intelligent technology-driven reinvention, or potentially for disruption that breaks things first and only bothers to pick up the pieces later.
As many of our readers will recall, New York has already learned some of this the hard way. Early this year, the City under Mayor Zohran Mamdani pulled the plug on its MyCity chatbot, launched by Mayor Eric Adams, after reporters caught it advising business owners to break the law. The City’s own required inventory of algorithmic tools now lists 86 of them being used for everything from handling 311 requests to flagging child welfare cases for review.
About half the authors in this issue take up the most practical question at hand for New York: how chatbots, AI agents, computer vision and old-fashioned data crunching can make government more efficient and effective, while avoiding the pitfalls. Many of the essays are reasonably optimistic about how AI can be used for good; that’s by design, because here at Vital City we are genuinely hopeful that innovations can be harnessed to make cities work better…(More)”
Article by Melissa Rosa and Bill Greer: “Commercial satellite imagery finer than 1 m is essential for humanitarian mapping, yet what providers call open ranges from searchable archives with clear reuse rights to a handful of samples licensed only for internal evaluation. This assessment reviews ten commercial optical and SAR providers across six dimensions: accessibility, searchability, licensing, currency and continuity, program support, and relevance. Four findings stand out:
01 Six providers lead, but none meets every humanitarian need. Vantor, Planet, Wyvern, Capella Space, ICEYE, and Umbra run substantial programs with clear reuse terms. Satellogic, Airbus, and Synspective offer partial access, and BlackSky offers no public imagery.
02 Open imagery covers the emergency, not what comes after. Programs either release imagery during major disasters (Vantor, Planet) or publish curated collections that showcase a sensor (Capella, ICEYE, Umbra, Wyvern). Neither reliably supports recovery, new baseline mapping, or preparedness.
03 Licensing is the biggest barrier. Non-commercial and evaluation-only terms rule out entire use cases, and only Vantor and Planet have explicitly permitted contributors to trace their imagery into OpenStreetMap.
04 Every element of a strong program already exists somewhere. No-login downloads, searchable catalogs, open licenses, regular releases, dedicated support, and published crisis protocols are each in practice at one or more providers. A shared standard is within reach…(More)”.
Paper by Ciro Cattuto & Alessandro Vespignani: “Complex systems have structural properties that make them a promising domain for scientific workflows driven by AI agents— systems that combine large language models with tool use and iterative execution. However, most complex systems simulators and libraries do not expose their control points and outputs in a form that text-based AI agents can readily use. Realizing the potential of agent-driven workflows requires equipping complex systems models with agent-friendly interfaces…(More)”.