Article by Vijayendra Rao: “In 1992, India amended its constitution to create some 250,000 elected village governments covering roughly 800 million people — the largest exercise in democratic decentralization in human history. The effects of this 73rd Amendment have varied enormously across states. In Kerala, an extraordinary People’s Campaign in 1996 created a system of nested participatory planning. Street-level groups deliberate on their needs, which are passed on to a ward-level assembly, then percolate upward to a village assembly where all expressed needs are prioritized and matched with budgets.
Over the course of the year, the agreed-upon projects are implemented and monitored in active collaboration with citizens.In other states, the same assemblies, created by the same amendment, are ceremonial rooms where nothing important is decided. In the 300 village-meeting transcripts that Paromita Sanyal and I analyzed for “Oral Democracy,” we found that differences in literacy, caste or wealth inequality did not explain how well these village assemblies worked. They were driven by whether the state government actually wanted decentralization to work – whether it devolved real money and real authority to the assemblies. The same constitutional amendment produced very divergent realities..(More)”.