Paper by Roger Koppl: “In a modern democracy, a public health system includes mechanisms for the provision of expert scientific advice to elected officials. The decisions of elected officials generally will be degraded by expert failure, that is, the provision of bad advice. The theory of expert failure suggests that competition among experts generally is the best safeguard against expert failure. Monopoly power of experts increases the chance of expert failure. The risk of expert failure also is greater when scientific advice is provided by only one or a few disciplines. A national government can simulate a competitive market for expert advice by structuring the scientific advice it receives to ensure the production of multiple perspectives from multiple disciplines. I apply these general principles to the United Kingdom’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (SAGE)….(More)”.
How to contribute:
Did you come across – or create – a compelling project/report/book/app at the leading edge of innovation in governance?
Share it with us at info@thelivinglib.org so that we can add it to the Collection!
About the Curator
Get the latest news right in your inbox
Subscribe to curated findings and actionable knowledge from The Living Library, delivered to your inbox every Friday
Related articles
Collective Intelligence
PEOPLE
The peer review crisis and the future of scholarly publishing: notes from the editorial frontline
Posted in September 17, 2026 by Stefaan Verhulst
DATA
Data Collaboratives
Open Data
Who decides what and how data is reused? Lessons learned from youth engagement and co-design for responsible data reuse in services
Posted in September 17, 2026 by Stefaan Verhulst
Artificial Intelligence
DATA
NYC Public Advocate Releases Report on AI Governance
Posted in September 16, 2026 by Stefaan Verhulst